I’m a huge fan of your books. They are amazing! I stumbled upon your wonderful books after I saw “Love Never Dies” at a theater in London. I was disappointed at the end of the play…the sequel doesn’t do the Phantom and the original story any justice. So I searched for sequels online. In my heart I always felt Erik was the one that deserved Christine’s love. Feeling quite dismal I found your book on Amazon which also had a preview I could read on Google books. I totally fell in love with your books. I read the first in a week and couldn’t put the next two down. Your books are so wonderful. They were exactly what I was looking for. Please put me on your email list!
Bronti
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

At last; my signed books arrived yesterday! Again I must say thanks, especially for the bookmarks along with the books (they will be my treasures) sounds as though I don't have a life huh? No, (your works) just thrill my senses, alas, this (book signing) is done. My sad, I may find another reason to chat with you some day. All good things to you and your future endeavors with our Phantom.

Toni in Arizona
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Greetings again. I just finished book three of the Phantom series - devoured them all within a weeks time! I was wondering if there is an anticipated release date for number four? I'm completely hooked on the roller coaster ride that you depict in these tales.
Sincerely, Jennifer
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I found your first book on Amazon and each book lead to the next. I love the touch of super natural in your books. Jumping into the realm of science fiction as you did in the last book is even better. Please complete your series. I do like these books and I would hate to be left hanging. Thank you for taking the time to write these books
Polly
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hi. I randomly stumbled upon your site and was just wondering where the music you have playing on there is from? It's really beautiful!
Allan H.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Boy, can you write!!!
Alex
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Yesterday I finished your 3rd book, I really enjoyed your story and I can't wait for the next one! Hopefully you plan to write many more. I'm addicted! I felt like Indiana Jones following your clues to the acrostics in the books! AWESOME! Very, very smart!
Agi in Italy
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I really enjoyed reading this book, can’t begin to tell you how cool I think it is. You’ve got a solid grip on this business of Erik’s evolution. I so understand why he left the chateau, as most of his remembered past and his recent injuries were weighing on him. What happens next is eating at me, but I’m going to be patient and WAIT. (Tapping fingers on the table like Christine.) What choice is there? Ha. I’m so looking forward to reading number four…hint, hint.
Selma
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I just finished The Tale of the Bloodline this evening. I loved it! Isidore and his laboratory of the "brave new world" show not only the marvels of science, but the danger of crossing certain barriers in the name of progress. The scenes that took place in Persia and the flashback to Erik's "closure" with his mother were fascinating and filled in many missing details in his life. I couldn't believe poor Erik's bad luck to lose his longed-for perfect face after falling into the pit. I can't wait to learn more about Torossian and what happens next as Erik and Christine continue on in the 21st century.
Elissa
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Can’t wait for the fourth book! Love the title of the fifth novel, The Theater of the Lost, sounds awesome. Your books will always be appreciated by me. I tried to write and have an idea what it takes to produce whole novels that hold the reader’s interest. I failed, but am thinking of giving it another go.
Rene
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

In The Tale of the Bloodline, Erik now finds himself in the 21st century. Here, he is a handsome, wealthy young man, the heir to the de Chagny estate. His father, Isidore de Chagny, is a renowned scientist. However, all is not as it seems. Isisdore is a reclusive man with many secrets, and Erik is haunted by dreams of the past. Although the story takes place in the present day, through fascinating flashbacks we are given much more information about the time that Erik spent with the Daroga in Persia. Isidore and his laboratory illustrate not only the wonders of modern science, but the danger of crossing certain barriers in the name of progress, and the ethical dilemmas that result. All in all, it is a splendid book. I look forward to reading the next installment of the story!
Johnnie's Angel
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Riveting! Oh gosh I could kiss this book! (I just did.) Now I’m going to read it again and get addicted to Erik over and over!
Caitlin
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

These books are good medicine for a broken heart. Your stories are magic; I open the cover and I’m in another world. Thank you. You have a gift.
Sammie
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

DISCOURSE WITH A PERSON WHO ORDERED ALL THREE NOVELS
Referencing the question: How did you discover my books?

ANSWER: Well, firstly, I am a fan of the character - the Phantom - and didn't feel quite fulfilled at the end of The Phantom of the Opera. I mean, what a character! I had so many questions. I could have just invented his story in my head, but I would have taken too many easy routes to a happy ending. I kind of like not having control over what happens to the character. :) So, I did a Wikipedia search of The Phantom of the Opera, and here's a long list of "adaptations." I scanned the titles under "literature," and there were three books written by you that actually picked up on the original story. But I was skeptical, so I found your books on Googlebooks which allowed me to read some pages from the actual books. I couldn't stop reading! And I was so distraught when the sample pages ended - I knew I had to read it all. I really enjoy the writing style - and the juicy bits. ;) I can't wait until the books arrive!
Frances, in New England

SIX DAYS LATER:
I received the books today! :) Thank you so much.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Erik in the pit of razor wire intrigued me a ton! What this story made me feel! I loved the book and I can't wait until the fourth. Regardless of what you write / what genre, I'm always going to buy them. I just love the way you spin a tale, it's so intelligent and well thought out. I loved the fact that Erik sang to Christine while she was in the tank because it was kind of how they were in the Opera House, Erik singing to her in her "dreams".
Splinter
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Your books are magic. I open the cover and I’m in another world. Thank you. This is such good medicine for my broken heart.
Alice
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

He lives…This author is an amazing man, if that is what he is. I cannot find him anywhere. But no matter, this is a story to top them all. Any one who can bring the Phantom back to me in such a truly glorious manner is worthy of praise...You will love the whole concept of what is done, I have read it twice now. Think of it this way, Erik and the Phantom together as never before. And of course Christine!
Toni F. Tucson, AZ
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Wonderful Work of Art!!!! This book is amazing. The third in a series about the infamous Phantom of the Opera, Erik. It's a sci-fi thriller that keeps the reader captivated throughout. The love scenes and excitement are totally worth reading the first two books to savor the third. The author has a unique way of writing about Erik, like he/she is digging in Erik's mind. The scenes mentioned in the book keep the reader on the edge of their seat, what is going to happen next? This book is totally, definently worth reading regardless of what kind of fan you are. It appeals to those who like romance, science-fiction, drama, anything and everything. Awesome book! PLEASE KEEP WRITING!
EriksKat
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

FABULOUS, FABULOUS AUTHOR!!!
The Wife of a Marine
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Thank you for taking time and being patient with the signing of my books. I want to apologize for not letting you and the Webmaster know that I had received them. I had promised that I would, but I was so delighted in getting them and reading what you’d signed…well, I guess I forgot. Anyway, thanks!
A Big Fan in Colorado
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

It seems that I’m going to spend the summer in anticipation. I just completed ordering the first two books. Now the hard part, waiting patiently for them to get here! The signed TheTale of the Bloodline came in yesterday's mail, with the bookmark. Thank you, thank you so very much. Now I’ll have my own personalized copies. (Did give my girlfriend back her set, she plans on sending she’s in.) I love what you write!! I didn’t realize there was a medical reason for what happened between Michael and Sarah in the second book. Goodness.
Jennifer D.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Even destroyed, your version of Erik is so beautiful, so demented. Yummy! Like your first two books, this story left me weak and trembling for Erik’s touch. Oh, Lordie, what I wouldn’t give to trade places with Christine.
Maddy
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I read your last book and just fell off the face of the earth! That's what you did to me!! It was fantastic, your writing was totally different, I almost didn't recognize you writing that book. And, you certainly do have a way with those sex and love scenes! Wow!! Your website certainly has expanded...with pictures and everything...you're doing great! I didn't notice any reviews about the book or possibly I missed them. What does everyone think...? My vision of Erik is just the same as yours. He is so beautiful!!
Jo-ann
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I am almost finished reading The Tale of the Bloodline and am enjoying it very much. As soon as I finish I’m going to start reading straight through from the first book. Thanks so much for signing them! I was amazed at how rapidly you got my little treasures back to me! I hope that by the fifth book Erik can regain his sense of humor, even as strange/twisted as it was…and the same for Christine. I do understand why they are serious toward each other in the latest novel. I would be too if I found my one truelove after 100+ years. And for now they are still quite young again. We’ve all been there and done that. Our teenage years were so very serious, even though the adults laughed and did not take us seriously. By the way, do you date?
Hot in the Desert
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

OMG. Your books are great. When is the next book coming?
Mary in Wisconsin
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I can tell that you are doing the thing (writing) that you love to do. Please praise yourself and pat yourself on the back. I am so looking forward to your next book. Will have to be content reading the first three for the present. Get the hint?
Ann from Down Under
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The love scenes were indeed worth the wait, I forgot to mention it because I was wrapped up in the pit, but I’m free now. The love scenes were GLORIOUS!! I enjoyed every minute of reading The Tale of the Bloodline. The book is a treasure. It’s like reading historical fiction…but not! How clever. I love this book right along with number one and two.
Stella-Bella

Author's note : This reader’s “pit” is a figurative reference to a college assignment.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

What a great book. To discover Torossian's true identity and that he was the cause of the catatonic seizures was creepy, creepy, creepy. It made my hair stand on end. I was totally unable to predict what was about to happen. I can so see the lead in to a fourth novel on the horizon. You have such a talented divertive brain. Thanks for sharing your writing with us. If any publishers catch wind of you, you'll be the next hot thing.
Susan R.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Five star ratings for your Tale of the Bloodline! You really held my interest with this story. Excellent news that writing another novel is still a viable option for you. Yah! I was so very ready for the sweet love scenes in this book - Earth shaking, and some very real battles to boot! Thanks for reassuring me that Erik is the only lover Christine will ever know in this lifetime.
Barbara
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Every time I had to put this book down to go class or study I got so angry. You fanned my curiosity from the very beginning with me wondering: Who in the Hell is Isidore de Chagny? Ha! What a mind you have.
Beverly D.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

It’s amazing that you are actually willing to communicate with the people who read your books. That alone makes you a precious commodity among the authors of the world. What a blessing for Erik to be reborn in the twenty-first century. His ideation may not always fit in with these modern times, but he’s sharp, he’ll learn fast. Loved the pictures on the front and the back covers.
Floyd
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

What an excellent story: so insightful, creepy, and at times hysterically funny. I could picture the scenes as I read them. I loved the spiraling plot. Several times I cringed and several times I chuckled. You use words as one would a paintbrush, and they all fit together so well. The colors are vivid. Certainly Leroux would have been most happy to pass on his mantle to you had he been able to read these tales.
Eddie
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Thank you for replying to my emails. You are a very prolific author and I enjoy your work so much. If I could, I’d prepay for The Disciples of the Night right now…where in the world did Erik and Torossian fly off to??? I know, you’re not telling. But maybe you’ll give us a sneak preview? Like in the Fifth Cellar?
Delta
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

How well you show us Erik, the lovesick ghoul with the mad passion bursting forth, the comic prankster, the insightful genius. Thank you. What a remarkable achievement you have managed! You overcame the hassles of the publisher’s production team and I’m so glad. This third segment of these stories resonates with heart! You made that big jump into modern times with such plausible genuinely-doable scientific reasons. I had a sneaky suspicion you’d pull this off.
Joan in Texas
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

That was so AWESOME! I actually got dizzy when Erik slipped into the pit!!! Never saw the erroneous step coming. I sat there with my mouth wide-open, I was that surprised. I was so taken with the entire scene. I see that it really had to be done, what was the former Erik to do?
Isabella
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Thanks for signing my books! I knew you weren’t a monster with a bad set of teeth and foul breath. Glad to hear you’re piecing together the next novel. No doubt you’ll answer the several questions birthed in the Epilogue of this book.
Cilia
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Stop saying this book is a “poor little orphaned thing”! I too wish advertising was not so devastatingly expensive. The love scene between Erik and Christine was worth the wait. You had me wondering if they would ever get together. Do I hear wedding bells in the future…oh baby, they are so hot once they get going!
Scott
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I love the continuity in all three novels. So take a deep breath and let me encourage you to pat yourself on the back. Your hard work shines through! I’m currently reading this third book (yes, I did read the first two); I only put it down to eat a meal or sleep. It may well be the best one yet.
Vivian
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

This book is a treasure! The story is fantastic, amazing. Twice this book actually made me giddy. First, when Erik fell into the pit. Second, when we discover that Khalil has traveled through with him. What a surprise about Torossian, though I should have picked up on the depth of the bond. I’m so glad that Christine remains important to Erik (what a bummer that he left for awhile), but what glorious love scenes you write! Yum. I don’t know that anyone else equals them.
A very avid Fan
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

LOL, I love this story. I love how you weave the past and present together so beautifully. Two tales at once and you never lose sight of the theme. You are quite talented. I really love reading your Phantom twists. Once again a great job!
Steven
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I am reading this latest book. A plus! You tied in the history so well, and now I understand why you wrote the other 2 books first. You had to for the continuity of the story line. (Very good thinking.) Please hurry along with The Disciples of the Night. It will be another book I will be looking forward to reading.
Mary
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Your stories never bore me! You have such great dramatic flare (along with that magical sprinkling of subtle humor). The problem is that as soon as I finish one of your books, I’m ready to read the next one. Sadly, I know I will have to wait awhile…like a year and a half.
Paul
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I know the last few months dealing with the publisher were hectic and frustrating for you, but I want to tell you how entertaining and satisfying this third novel is! I enjoyed reading every chapter. It’s as good as the first two books. The trials and the wait were so worth the haul. Congratulations!
A Fan in Arizona
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hard to actually pick my favorite scene, there's just so many I like. The book is really good! It's mesmerizing. I was constantly interested to see what would happen next. When I got to the point where Erik was learning the ways of the Punjab lasso and making a cat noise to scare that couple, I wanted to cheer. How he caught them was such a really cool work of art. There are just so many interesting moments so far and I'm barely halfway through! Can’t wait to finish this book.
Jonathan
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

About the art gallery, those are very cool pictures. The top one is especially freaky. Of course I'm guessing that Torossian, from the description of him in the book, is supposed to be a quite a bit freaky. Also, very brave of you to hit matricide head on, some women were never meant to be mothers - mine for sure. Bravo, I so applaud your work.
Cleo in Canada
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

So glad you got this book birthed into the world. This story has some very grim scenes and some contrasting very funny parts (the panty raid for one. That scene was really funny. I could so see young Erik doing that.) You must sleep with your mind’s eye writing. I enjoy your plots so much; they are never a disappointment. You confront some really horrendous issues and opened my eyes about the legal rights of clones. Also, please thank the Webmaster for maintaining a very interesting website.
Maude
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Purple is a good color for this book. A world of shadows and turncoats, un-summoned visions that influence and educate. Quite a page-turner.
Maureen
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

In a very subtle way, your books discuss the very precious need for tolerance among the people of the world, and I so agree with you. So many think that tolerance is a sign of weakness, or they just can't be bothered to be tolerant because it's "too much of an effort". What shallow, emptiness. Although, in looking back, I can understand why Erik found it almost impossible to be tolerant. I mean, look at how he was treated. It would be enough to severely anger anybody; and to be unaccepted / unloved / uncared for / unwanted for his entire life would have been totally heart-shattering. I can imagine his take on tolerance being, "Ha! Why should I tolerate people? They have NEVER tolerated me!”
Australia
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I want to congratulate you again for releasing the book. I really do - you know I'm proud of you for coming this far when you wanted to chuck it all in. It took real guts and the stamina to get through it. I wish I had half your determination sometimes.
G. S.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Torossian is a pretty interesting character. I half-wondered if Christine would have a leftover twin. Didn’t appear to happen since she was in the tank by herself. When Christine came out of the tank and Erik came in to meet her at breakfast and Dillard interfered, I actually Grrred at Dillard. I really like this story; it's stranger, more like sci-fi. I really loved the medical aspect of it. I had a feeling the character named Kathryn would not stay as loyal as I thought she would be. Erik mentally pulling back into Persia and going into an arena was absolutely fascinating. All through the story I kept wondering how things were going to play out.
Anonymous
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

OK, take a break from writing for a little while; everyone needs a break now and then. But you write such wonderful stuff, Etienne. Please keep the stories coming! The Tale of the Bloodline was especially poignant. Can’t wait for The Disciples of the Night.
Julie a true fan!
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

You made my heart tremble and soar with this novel. I loved this book. Erik had to fall into the pit, he just didn’t seem right not deformed. Whew! Now he’s even more interesting than before.
A Reader - Massachusetts
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I arrived home at 8:15 pm tonight to find my book had finally been delivered. When I put the brown covered parcel down on the table I stared, tried to open it, stopped....my granddaughter looked at me in all seriousness and said, “I’ll open it for you, Nan. It’s Etienne’s book isn’t it?” “Yes”’, I said. I’ll leave you with that because I am just so excited to have it, and I wanted you to know how I felt. The infusion has finally started, and I fully intend to keep the needle stuck in my vein and the solution going. I will keep you informed as I read along. Thanks again, Etienne, I feel that once again you’ve started something really special.
A Grandmother with a Young Heart
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I’m so glad I bought this book. One of the great things about this book is that it’s nothing like real life. It’s an incredible journey. Not disappointing at all. I love your books, no matter what you put in them. You’re an outstanding writer and don’t let anyone ever tell you otherwise. Really interesting, and there are characters from my state of North Carolina! Great details. A wonderful read.
Saul
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Sorry that it took such a knock down, drag out fight to get the text and cover right with the publisher. How frustrating that people paid to perform a service want to mess with things. I have to tell you that I like the turn your books have taken, this one seems more science-fiction/thriller/drama. You are so clever. It’s so interesting finding out where Erik is going and how he learns to cope with his visions. Oh, and I am not lending this book out until I’ve read it a second time, just like I did with Breaking Dawn. I have even read parts of this one aloud! The events seem so real! It’s like my mind takes pictures of what you describe. (Coming off the mountain, locked in a cage, I felt my hands and knees get scraped on the rough floorboards! And how inventive is Erik, to use his time in the dungeons so well!)
Velvet
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

As usual, your words are expertly written and precise, down to all your crossed t’s and the dotted i’s. I can’t help but feel that you have been what you write and you write to make me, the reader, feel what you feel. I have to read this slowly. I have to take everything in. I can’t allow myself to miss a detail. If I do, I have to read it over again. This story is definitely different and I feel like I am going to be on a long, narrow, but smooth ride all the way. You are doing it again. I am taking Erik into my life again and it has been such a long time. Right now, I am a little jealous that he has been away so long. I have been starved for lack of reading about him. These are my honest feelings. I feel ready and calm and will continue to read, desperate for more information.
A Fellow Writer
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I love every minute I spend reading this book. I have no idea what I’m going to draw yet, I might do more than one for this one because I kind of want to draw one where he’s in Persia, and one in modern time. Well, I am going to continue reading and enjoying. Thank you so much for being such a wonderful friend and author, you have an amazing gift. God bless you!
A Fan
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Congratulations! I really liked the plot of this third book. It’s surprising and very different from the concept of your first two novels. Now I understand why you wrote that each component of the trilogy was a story unto itself. Found some portions absolutely gripping, they had me right on the edge of my seat.
A Messenger from the Crypt
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Wow! You are very creative…exceptionally so. These characters, especially Erik, make me feel alive! Thank you for letting us live and feast inside this young man’s thoughts. What an awesome place to be!
A Compatriot
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

How frustrating it must have been to get through all those darn mistakes generated by the production team at the publisher. I can’t even image the frustration you must have gone through each time you received another proof. Just remember what a wonderful thing you are doing for all of us admirers! Please know that I am a huge fan of yours.
The Maker of Jeweled Purses
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I read book # 1 and # 2 almost simultaneously. I had such a great time! Now I shall devour book # 3 like a wolf on the prowl! Love your writing, even the annoying big words.
K.C.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Oh, chivalrous knight, I am so very proud of you. You really pushed through a self-confidence barrier to get this novel out there and I think you are so incredibly brave.
Gem
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hooray, I’m infused and bloodied. Your evil genius is quite brilliant! I really sunk my teeth into your third book and am already for a fourth (haha). My mouth is open and I’m drooling for more. I so totally know that Erik won’t be able to keep his hands off Christine for long!!
A Bostonian
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Your plots are unlike any of the Phantom stories I’ve every read before. I could never predict what was about to happen. The horror and the drama are so believable. I found myself holding my breath, as I felt like I was in the story with the characters. Now my brain is racing, this plot is so full of ideas and you could go down any number of channels from here.
A fan in Sterling
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

My hope and only genuine concern is that other people will catch onto these outstanding works of yours. I hope they read them, talk about them, promote them and get you where you belong…which is way up there on the Best Authors List. What a pity if there isn’t another book to follow this one. It is now 1:30 am and I’m still awake holding this latest edition to the story. I honestly can’t wait to read the next segment. I have so many questions, so many comments. My heart is full and breaking. I truly appreciate the time and courage you’ve mustered to write these books. The energy you’ve summoned when you really didn’t have anymore to draw from. It’s an honor just to know you. You’ll insist the webmaster take this down, but I’ll insist that he doesn’t. Love you.
Your Sister
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The book is really, really good. It’s so totally fascinating. I’m so interested to see what happens next. I’m currently on page 305 and really enjoying it. I just wish I could read more, but I have to study for a test! You can bet I’ll be picking it up as soon as I’m clear of the auditorium. (I’m taking the book with me!) There are so many amazing scenes and I’m having difficulty deciding which one I like best. There are just so many interesting moments, and I’m barely halfway through. I’m where Erik is learning the ways of the Punjab lasso and making a cat noise to scare that couple meeting secretly in the garden cabinet. It’s so really cool. I have no idea what’s about to happen. I wish I could see the Arabian horses you describe, they must be magnificent. Imagine a parade of them set to Persian music! How wild!
Stephanie
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

All the anticipation and waiting for this book was worth it! I made sure that no one bothered me when I read it. I love this book! I ordered the hard cover edition, and it’s still here in my hands. I’ve zipped through its pages, absorbing all I could on the first read threw. I didn’t want it to end! It is exceptionally poignant and definitely different from other Phantom literature. The plot is exciting and left me even more curious than when I started. What happens from here? We are standing in a room of mirrors, each section of the panels can open as a doorway. Which one do we open next? The choice is in the hands of this amazing author.
The Librarian
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Stayed up all night reading this book, it's got to be the best one yet. Oh my gosh, please don't leave it here. Whatever it takes, carry on.
Stephen
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I was surprised that you wrote to me. I've know the history from the book of Gaston Leroux, but for me it was always like...unfinished. You know - I feel regret, not satisfaction when I finish Leroux’s book. Next was a book of Suzanne Kay, Phantom, and I was think that will be finish of my adventure with Erik, Christine and Raoul, and then I find you by accident on Google. But you see - you wrote your books in such way that for person who's not use your language every day (as you see English is not my native language - I'm from Poland) those books is not to hard for reading - thanks for that!) Let me tell you - Gaston Leroux make a persons, Suzanne Kay give them history - and you give them life! These are great books. You make them and I'll read them always!
Agata Bugala - Poland

Author’s note: Write back as you like. I will always try to respond. Several readers are surprised that I personally answer emails, but if you knew me, you wouldn't be surprised. You are the only individual I'm corresponding with in Poland. That makes you very unique. I would like to tell you that I'm glad you found my books on Google and that you enjoyed reading them. Your English is fine. I understand it and that you enjoyed my books makes me smile. Trust me, you are doing much better with English than I would do with Polish. I hope you enjoy what's going to happen next with Erik in The Tale of the Bloodline. As you can probably tell, I like exploring both science and the supernatural arenas in my writing.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I don't need to say this, but you are such a decent writer...to me and the others who bought the first two books. At least you've finished two books. I'm still struggling with one. (chuckles) I bet you were happy to have quiet again. The hermit returns to his cave, perhaps? You've mentioned many times that you would be happy to live like that. Yet your busy brain needs to work, all the time. It's horrible. I know. Like physically, being dragged behind a Ferrari while wearing roller blades -- you're screwed if you fall over. Whether or not you believe it will not change the fact that there are people who believe in you and your writing. You can remain convinced that you are no writer and are unfit to polish the boots of Charles Dickens, but even the greats started somewhere. Thanks for all the help you’ve given me with my writing. I’ll wheel in the cheerleading squad if I have to – beams – you know I will! You can’t just leave us hanging. Heck, I really want to know what happens! The Season of the Witch is such an enjoyable read. After all, if I did not like it, I would not read it again and again, would I? I just ambled through the game of Turnabout…so funny. I wouldn’t worry about people liking your work, you haven’t disappointed your fans thus far!
Gemma
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I am so looking forward to the third book and going back to Erik’s beginnings. You did great, in my opinion, on the first two books. I think my favorite so far is the first one, since it’s about Erik and Christine, and the second was about putting an end to the saga of the Phantom of the Opera and his family.
Lancaster
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Please do let me know just as soon as you hear the release date...thanking you in advance, your friend, and faithful reader, waiting for the next book, that doesn't have a date yet, that I can't buy yet, and definitely can't read yet because I can't buy it, because I don't have a date...yet. So, let me know just as soon as you can.
Jo-ann
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I am a patient person, have learned to be, but I can hardly wait for your next book. From what I’ve read from your statements to other readers, this third book is pretty much going on a different path. I am actually not disappointed that you didn't continue on the family. Anyone should know, if they think about it, that the children are bound to have dysfunctional things going on in their lives. Everyone, if they are honest, has skeletons rattling in their lives that make us all a little insane at times, but some people can hide them better than others. Your scenes where the Phantom tries to cope with his disabilities and displays a great sense of humanity, tenderness, etc. are my favorite.
Mary C.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I just read the information about The Tale of the Bloodline, and now it's got me going. He no longer has a ghoulish face? Is it Erik reborn, and who follows after him? This is getting to sound really good now. How far away are we? Oh yes, you can send me an advanced copy as a present, a Christmas present. You got to help me here...there is nothing to read out there.
Bread Pudding Lover
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I want to be infused! Let’s get hooked up and get the blood flowing! I can’t wait for this book to be done. This is the one you wanted to publish when you started all this. All of Etienne de Mendes' books are to me what 'Twilight' is to other people. I wish we could announce to the world, “Look, look at Etienne’s books...great books, with an amazingly, powerful author. Don't waste anymore of your time, read these books!” I can’t say enough. I so missed reading a new book from you. And you are such a wonderful person to correspond with a cyberspace fan, you are!
A Boston Fan
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I do have to mention that I noticed the new cover of 'Bloodline'. A complete picture of our phantom! Great cover, great drawing and artwork and such a surprise...and, such a great summary of what your readers are going to have very soon. I can't believe I can almost grasp the third book in my hand! I look forward so much to reading this book, since this is the one you wanted to write from the beginning! I'm on pins and needles. Let me know the moment it hits the runway and is ready to be shipped.
Giovanna
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Phantom of the Opera

The Opera Ghost Returns

The Paris Opera House

The Return of the Phantom

The Season of the Witch

The Tale of the Bloodline

Etienne de Mendes

The Phantom

Christine Daae

Madame Giry

"Feast your eyes, glut your soul on my cursed ugliness!"